An automated review system rejected your insurance claim. The response was a form letter — "not covered," "pre-existing condition," or "not medically necessary." No human reviewed your case. Here is what you can do.
The Core Problem
Insurance companies increasingly use AI to triage and deny claims automatically. The algorithm flags your claim against a set of criteria and issues a denial without a human reviewing the specifics of your situation. This creates a systematic problem: nuanced cases that a human adjuster might approve are rejected by a pattern-matching system.
Across jurisdictions, regulators are increasingly hostile to purely automated significant decisions — particularly in health and life insurance. You have more leverage than the denial letter suggests.
EU / UK: Right to Human Review
Under GDPR Article 22, you have the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing that produces significant legal effects. GDPR Art.22 An insurance claim denial is clearly a significant effect. You can:
- Request that the decision be reviewed by a human
- Express your point of view
- Contest the decision
Article 22 has three exceptions where solely automated decisions are permitted: (a) when the decision is necessary for entering into or performing a contract, (b) when authorised by EU or member state law, or (c) when based on your explicit consent. Insurance claims often fall under (a). Crucially, even within these exceptions, Article 22(3) preserves your right to obtain human intervention, express your point of view, and contest the decision. An insurer cannot use the "necessary for the contract" defence to refuse you a human review.
The insurer must tell you that the decision was automated, tell you about the existence of your Article 22 rights, and provide a mechanism to exercise them. From August 2026, the EU AI Act adds an additional right to a clear explanation of the AI's role in the decision (Article 86), where the system used qualifies as high-risk under Annex III. AI Act Art.86
In the UK, the FCA Consumer Duty (2023) requires firms to act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers. FCA Duty An automated denial that produces a poor outcome without adequate review and explanation is potentially a Consumer Duty breach. The Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) can adjudicate.
US: State Insurance Regulations
There is no single federal right to human review, but most states have insurance regulations requiring:
- A specific reason for the denial (not just a policy reference)
- An internal appeals process
- For health insurance: independent medical review when "not medically necessary" is cited
The Affordable Care Act (ACA) requires health insurers to offer internal and external appeals for denied claims. External review must be conducted by an independent organisation, not the insurer. ACA
What to Do
- Request the specific reason — ask them to identify the specific policy clause or criterion that led to the denial, and whether it was decided by a human or an automated system.
- Request human review — in the EU/UK, cite GDPR Article 22. In the US, cite your state's insurance appeals process. In all cases, put this in writing.
- Get supporting documentation — for health claims, get a letter from your doctor specifically addressing the insurer's stated reason for denial.
- Use the internal appeals process — document everything. Most external dispute resolution requires you to exhaust internal appeals first.
- Escalate externally:
- EU/UK: Financial Ombudsman Service (UK), or your national financial regulator
- US: Your state insurance commissioner's office. File at your state's Department of Insurance website.
"I am writing to formally request human review of this automated denial under GDPR Article 22 / [state insurance code]. Please confirm whether this decision was made solely by automated processing and provide the specific criteria applied to my claim."
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an AI deny my insurance claim without human review?
In the EU and UK, significant automated decisions require human review under GDPR Article 22 and insurance conduct rules.
What is a prior authorization denial in health insurance?
When an insurer refuses to cover a treatment before it is performed. You can appeal with medical documentation and demand human review.
How do I force a human review of an AI claim denial?
Submit a written appeal citing GDPR Article 22 (EU/UK) or your state insurance department rules (US), and attach supporting medical or policy evidence.
Related Guides
Fix AI has an insurance claim denial case (InsureCore Health) where an AI flags your claim as "not medically necessary." Practice the right arguments to force a human review — for free.
Practice This Dispute Free →